NEW RULE LIMITING ORAL ARGUMENTS ON APPEAL

“Silence is the perfectest herald of joy; I were but little happy, if I could say how much.”
— - MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING act 2, sc. 1

Effective November 2, 2026, oral argument in the Tennessee Court of Appeals is now granted at the discretion of the Court.  This changes the long-standing practice of having oral argument whenever one of the parties on appeal requests it. The Court adopted new language to Tennessee Court of Appeals Rule 16(a) which is set forth below:

(a) Oral argument is granted in the discretion of the Court. If a party has requested oral argument in accordance with Tennessee Rule of Appellate Procedure 35(a), the clerk may set the case for oral argument unless the Court directs otherwise. Notwithstanding a party’s request under Rule 35(a), the Court may direct that a case be submitted for a decision on the record and briefs if the Court determines that the record and briefs adequately present the facts and legal arguments, that oral argument would not significantly aid the Court in deciding the appeal, or due to material deficiencies with the briefing or record.

(b) Oral argument may be conducted in person or remotely as directed by the Court.

You can read the Court’s Order and the Amended rule here.

My first reaction to this rule is that I was not aware this was even under consideration.  I understand the Court’s desire to have better control of their docket. I also understand that there is likely some cost-savings to be had on behalf of clients if there is no oral argument on a case. I am hopeful that the Court will still grant oral argument in a significant number of cases, however, because thirty years of practice have taught me that there is value in having judges and attorneys carve out time for a spirited discussion of the important issues being addressed. And many clients appreciate having their literal day in court. Even if they do not prevail, they have the opportunity to experience the justice systema t work and see what the judges do. This can be an important part of building respect for the rule of law.  

I will be writing more on this in future blogs. This new rule is a substantial development in appellate practice in Tennessee, which merits continued observation and discussion. And, of course, I’d be happy to hear your thoughts on this, dear readers.









Next
Next

Know Your Audience