The team at Dodson Parker Behm & Capparella, PC shares updates and thoughts on developments in the law.

Timing, Sophistication of Parties Key Factors in Prenup Enforceability

October 2, 2017

The Tennessee Court of Appeals recently reinforced longstanding principles in determining the enforceability of prenuptial agreements. Among the factors a court examines carefully in determining whether a prenup will be upheld are the timing of the presentation of the document and the relative experiences of the parties in terms of age and educational background.  Failure to account for these differences can be fatal to enforceability, since the party seeking to have a prenup enforced bears the burden of proof.

In Grubb v. Grubb,  the wife, then aged 20, was presented with the prenuptial agreement at the office of the attorney representing her soon-to-be husband, who was 42 years old.  The meeting took place two days before the parties left for their destination wedding.  The trial court noted that Mrs. Grubb possessed her G.E.D. and worked at a dry cleaners when the couple met.  Mr. Grubb, on the other hand, had a college degree and had assets in the amount of $5,000,000 and an annual income of approximately $500,000.

While the trial court upheld the agreement with the exception of purported caps on alimony, the Tennessee Court of Appeals determined that Mrs. Grubb’s opportunity to consult independent counsel was illusory.  Accordingly, the prenup was unenforceable.

Post by: Jillian Mastroianni

 


▼  More from the Blog  ▼


<h2 class="widget-title widgettitle">CONTRIBUTORS</h2><!-- [et_pb_line_break_holder] --><!-- [et_pb_line_break_holder] -->


  • RECENT NEWS

    • Tyler Yarbro’s Brief Quoted in Tennessean Article

      Tyler Yarbro, Appellate Counsel for Lindsey Lowe, filed the principal brief arguing why the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals should uphold the ruling of Honorable Dee David Gay of Sumner County granting Lindsey Lowe …
    • DPBC Inclement Weather Update

      Due to inclement weather, our office in Germantown is closed, but all attorneys and staff are working remotely. You can still reach us by calling our main number or by email. Stay safe and …
    • Parker Presents for Tennessee Probate Seminar

      Paul S. Parker was a featured presenter for the National Business Institute’s OnDemand Course on December 15, 2023. The program, entitled Tennessee Probate Process from Start to Finish, seeks to provide attorneys and other …
<!-- [et_pb_line_break_holder] --><h4><strong>Tweets</strong> <span class="timeline-Header-byline" data-scribe="element:byline">by <span style="color: #449ccf;"><a class="customisable-highlight" style="color: #449ccf;" title="‎@dodsonparker on Twitter" href="https://twitter.com/dodsonparker">‎@dodsonparker</a></span></span></h4><!-- [et_pb_line_break_holder] --><!-- [et_pb_line_break_holder] -->[fts_twitter twitter_name=dodsonparker tweets_count=1 cover_photo=no stats_bar=no show_retweets=no show_replies=no]

Dodson Parker Behm and Capparella PC
1310 Sixth Avenue North
Nashville, TN 37208

Ph. 615-254-2291 | Directions

Terms of Use
Copyright Policy


The information found on this website is not intended as legal advice. You should not act on any information contained within the website without consulting legal counsel regarding your particular situation.

We’re proud to call Nashville’s Historic Germantown Neighborhood our home.
You’ll find us here 7:30 am – 5:00 pm weekdays.

Privacy Policy